Yahoo Answers is shutting down on 4 May 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Native Americans/American Indians: What do you think of Census 2010?

I was thinking about how many Hispanic/Latino people are selecting/going to select American Indian as (at least one of) their race(s). This means our population is going to grow from 1% to who knows how much. In the process though, tribal members will be flooded by descendants and these newly defined people. The media isn't going to care about the difference between tribal members and the others and, while the statistics are going to show extreme growth of our subgroup, it isn't going to be an accurate accounting of who WE really are. The detailed report will show the differences but not many people read those reports. Most people will just look at the quick stats and assume that now American Indians make up 25% or more (my guess) of the US population. What a mess! Your thoughts?

Update:

What I'm specifically refering to is Question 9: What is your Race? Hispanic/Latino people who mark Yes for Question 8 still must mark a race. I am fully aware and realize that any person with indigenous roots in any part of America (North, South, or Central) is included in the definition provided on the form and that many Hispanic/Latino will select American Indian as their race whether they can provide a tribe name or not. This is just reality. What this will do though is statistically drown out the "Native Americans" of the US. We're such a small group anyway (less than 1% of the total population if you just count enrolled tribal members of US-based tribes).

Update 2:

Also, just so everyone is aware, if you do not chose a race on the census form or write in something off like "Human," the Census Bureau will send someone to your address to knock on the door. That Census worker will use "observer identification" to select a race for you based on how you look. "Observer Identification" is an OMB (Office of Management and Budgets) directive when people fail to answer the race question. The Census Bureau follows OMB's directive.

12 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favourite answer

    well I'm actually one of those hispanic/latino people (don't really like the label), anyways me and my family actually decided not mark down american indian/alaskan because it would seem a bit disrespectful. We were also under the impression that it only applied to those of the U.S region NOT mexico and the rest of central * south america. It might suck for you guys, but maybe people will finally understand what "hispanics/latinos" are. I highly doubt this will go unnoticed and it actually might help you guys out (MAYBE). So what ended up doing is marking the hispanic label/mexican and inputting the term "mestizo".

  • 1 decade ago

    Not long ago I came across a web page cautioning Native Americans not to list any other race on the census. The information stated Native Americans can not claim any other heritage. If they do they would not be counted as Native Americans and that would effect program funding.

    I know that in previous censuses that if other ethnic groups claim Native American, they are not counted in Native American statistics. The census data at the following link shows :

    White + Native American 0.4%

    Black + Native American 0.1%

    Native American + some other race (93,842) 0.0%

    The races are isolated by “Not Hispanic or Latino” but the Native American + another race is 0.

    This data made me think that the caution may well be a valid one.

    U.S. Census Bureau

    http://factfinder.census.gov/servlet/QTTable?_bm=y...

    .

  • 1 decade ago

    To the contrary, the 2010 census has finally defined Hispanic as an ethnicity, and recognized that the Hispanic identity is made up of different races and nationalities. If someone considers themselves both Hispanic and a native American, they have to be able to identify what tribe/nation they belong to, a task not easily accomplished by someone who may have some biological aboriginal ancestry, but has no social or cultural ties to a native American nation.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    In the census 2000, they counted Latino American Indians as Native American population. They had third largest group. Most Amerindian Latino won't mark down American Indian, for reason I don't want to explain. Anyways, It's asking for race, not culture...

    In the Census, American Indians are defined as the Indigenous people of North, Central, and South America. I'm a Central American Amerindian. I marked down American Indian, and wrote down the specific ethnic group/tribe I come from.

  • 5 years ago

    i would stay stick with what comes natural the big things that are important to us native people that being the things that are still keeping our people down. e.g. health care on the rez, health care in general, political issues that still come up today, the past military contributions we have given but are never given credit for and the elders that still teach us younguns how things should be. another thing Boris your an idiot you should not have even answered the question at all if you couldn't read the disclaimer at the end and follow it like any self respecting individual would have. Oh Yeah I'm a listener of the show and have been on there with crazy and she does one hell of a job with what she does keep in up Girl.

  • 1 decade ago

    Why should it even bother you? You should be worried about your own tribe's population and the people trying to claim membership.

    You don't see African Americans worrying that the black population will rise because of the Afro Latinos and African Immigrants checking black. Or white Americans getting upset when European Immigrants check white. Just worry about the population of your tribe! Many of the U.S Indians are mixed with European or African anyway. It's not like the Hispanic Indians are going to claim your tribe or anything, white people do that. So what if people think the Indian's population is higher or not. You guys are cousins and Europeans have screwed both you guys over. Stop whining about stuff like this. Do you want to feel special?

    And don't worry, not many Latinos will be checking American Indian. It's the opposite in Latin American. It's not cool to be an Indian. They find it offensive. The ones checking Indian probably can relate to the suffering of your people.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    6 years ago

    To belong to any original tribe of the u.s you have to be enrolled that is is a process decided by the tribal government you have to prove a direct immediate ancestry by family

  • 1 decade ago

    Personally, I'm getting sick of everyone, EVERYONE, in this section saying, I am part Native American, I'm mixed with Native American, my great great (like 5 more great) grandparents were Native American.....so darn sick of this. Is it so bad just to be white and stay that way? Whats the point in trying to claim that 1 drop of Native blood, seriously? If they get a nosebleed, oops, there goes that little drop of Native.......Its not right, new-agers and wanna-be's are killing me, I'm so glad they can't do anything but "claim" Native, because of our enrollment offices, they can never be real Natives, my Tribe has a 1/2 degree requirement, so not just anyone can say they are part of the Oglala Nation. I don't see how this "trend" came to be, but I think all Natives are tired of hearing this "I'm part Native" thing.

    Source(s): Oglala Lakota
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Worse yet, its not going to 25% is pureblood, its going to be made up of those 1/50505000 types!

    All over, my Grandmother was part cherokee, should I put I'm Native on the census?

    No, they shouldn't

  • 1 decade ago

    i believe you should be given your own nation where you can grow a large population.

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.