Yahoo Answers is shutting down on 4 May 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 6

Do you agree with this view of Fundamentalism?

This was from the Pontifical Biblical Commission during Pope John Paul II's Papacy:

"The fundamentalist approach is dangerous, for it is attractive to people who look to the Bible for ready answers to the problems of life. It can deceive these people, offering them interpretations that are pious but illusory, instead of telling them that the Bible does not necessarily contain an immediate answer to each and every problem. Without saying as much in so many words, fundamentalism actually invites people to a kind of intellectual suicide. It injects into life a false certitude, for it unwittingly confuses the divine substance of the biblical message with what are in fact its human limitations"_Pontifical Biblical Commission(The Interpretation of the Bible in the Church).

Update:

@Annsan_In_Him here is a a fuller statement:

"Fundamentalism is right to insist on the divine inspiration of the Bible, the inerrancy of the Word of God and other biblical truths included in its five fundamental points. But its way of presenting these truths is rooted in an ideology which is not biblical, whatever the proponents of this approach might say. For it demands an unshakeable adherence to rigid doctrinal points of view and imposes, as the only source(continued)

Update 2:

of teaching for Christian life and salvation, a reading of the Bible which rejects all questioning and any kind of critical research"

4 Answers

Relevance
  • Nous
    Lv 7
    4 years ago
    Favourite answer

    Fundamentalism is NOT Chrsitinaity in any way shape or form!

    FUNDAMENTALIST: an adherent of fundamentalism, a religious movement characterized by a strict belief in the literal interpretation of religious texts.

    Pope Francis says the theories of evolution and the Big Bang are real and God is not “a magician with a magic wand” putting an end to the “pseudo theories” of creationism and intelligent design! So the Catholic Church, Church of England and mainstream churches all accept the big bang and evolution!

    Lord Carey the former Archbishop of Canterbury put it rather well – “Creationism is the fruit of a fundamentalist approach to scripture, ignoring scholarship and critical learning, and confusing different understandings of truth”!

    Nice that Christians and atheists can agree and laugh together but sadly at God’s expense!

  • 4 years ago

    "Fundamentalists" are the Christian equivalent to "Taliban" for Islam.

    They perform the exact same "role": finding twisted interpretations of the Bible, then trying to impose them on others.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    4 years ago

    Yes.

    Source(s): own
  • 4 years ago

    First I would need to know the pope's definition of the word 'Fundamentalism'. That is not given in the quote. I can only glean a few clues, such as those "who look to the Bible for ready answers to the problems of life". Does this mean that Catholicism does NOT look to the Bible for ready answers to the problems of life? Does Catholicism not believe the Bible can give sound and clear direction for that? Has Catholicism not provided such answers to its own flock, based on the Bible?

    As for how Fundamentalism "injects into life a false certitude", does not Catholicism give its flock an equally false certitude in its religious system (with which biblical certitude has been replaced)? And is not the pope really talking about pseudo-Christian cult control when it speaks of 'false certitude'? Of course, if he equates Fundamentalism with pseudo-Christian control, then he would speak like that. But what IS 'Fundamentalism'?

    This is a word much bandied about, but never explained! We are all left to imagine what 'Fundamentalism' is, yet should not every Christian know the fundamentals of his religion? Should not all Catholics have a clear and enthusiastic grip on the fundamentals of their Catholic religion? Should they not eagerly grasp the interpretation their leaders give them, even if not biblically based? Are not Catholics often guilty of intellectual suicide themselves by just going through rituals, trusting in them to be saved?

    Well, the pope is clearly speaking about some Protestants who place great value on the Bible as authority for answering life's problems. Given that many Catholics place great value on their pope and priests as authority for answering life's problems, I cannot agree with the pope. He is merely replacing one source of authority with another - himself.

    To conclude, here is a wee quote from a Protestant theologian who flags up another area of Protestantism that is problematic today, but which Catholicism has been guilty of itself:

    "The Charismatic Movement is doing exactly what the Galatian Christians were doing and what medieval Catholicism was doing: underestimating, minimising, eroding the significance of our being in Christ. The moment we are in Him we have everything: all the promises of God; everything that He has (Romans 8:17)."

    If we must choose between Protestant error and Catholic error, I suggest we err on the safe side and seek to find our reasons in God's holy word, the Bible, rather than in human interpretations. After all, Christians have the indwelling Holy Spirit who guides us into all truth, as Jesus promised - John 14:26 & 15:26 & 16:7-17. Very few Catholics seem to even know this, let alone trust in the blessed Holy Spirit enlightening them. That could account for the gross biblical illiteracy of most Catholics.

    EDIT - Thanks for the additional info Janhoi. I must raise this claim, "it demands an unshakeable adherence to rigid doctrinal points of view and imposes, as the only source of teaching for Christian life and salvation, a reading of the Bible which rejects all questioning and any kind of critical research." I thought I could see who the pope was referring to - until I got to that bit! In all my 36 years as a Christian, I have only come across a handful of people (and mainly on here) who reject all questioning and any kind of critical research. But they don't congregate under the banner of "Fundamentalism"! You can find examples of them in a wide range of denominations. I guess that if most of these "Fundamentalists" are in America, that's why I can hardly identify them.

    But the real problem remains - there is no denomination called "Fundamentalism". There is no credal statement of Fundamentalists, no confession of their faith! This means they are a moving target, and anybody shouting, "Fundamentalist!" can take a pop-shot at them without the rest of us actually knowing who they supposedly are!

    Source(s): A Faith To Live By, p. 102, Donald MacLeod
Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.